猎魔人第二季

看到S2E2终于觉得不对，忍不住了。我可真是后知后觉。

先来说说第一部的优点，有几处精彩的打戏，有几处精彩的改编，虽然肉眼可见的低成本，但尽最大诚意还原了该有的大场景；虽然因为剧情容量所限，削减了部分角色剧情，但好在叙事手法应用得当颇具新意。

那么好了，第二部给了我们什么？

在北方诸国出现了完全两样的气候，一边下暴风，一边树木长青。你当这是西伯利亚和地中海诸国吗？——行，为了塑造不同的情绪，勉强能接受。

理论上最少最少要花半个月时间（即使不讨论背景设定，现实里跨越气候带的路程会很短吗），杰洛特和希里还是单衣最多加个裘。——行，影棚拍戏穿太厚，太热了出汗就出戏了，勉强接受。

一队精灵贵族难民（甚至不是松鼠党，这有本质区别，不论是战斗风格还是嗜血程度二者都完全不同），用莫名其妙的大粗木头尖子捅死一队尼弗迦德指挥官小队并俘虏了两个女术士（甚至还要在后面幻境里圆一下，叶奈法失去了力量）——行，节省成本降低非主线的打斗预算，勉强接受。甚至你整个叶奈法线都是拙劣的谜语人戏码也无所谓。悬疑嘛，稍微调节调节气氛。

第一集的主线肤浅，别扭，我听说猎魔人的编剧既看不起游戏也看不起原著，那么怎么能写出这种劣质惊悚片套爱情片的剧本。 刻意创造疑点，又刻意让主人公不在乎。明明前面的剧情已经在凶案现场却刻意忽略线索，都到了怪物居所猎魔人的嗅觉、听觉甚至视觉统统失效，还非得回现场一趟，作一番拙劣的推理（能飞的怪物可多了，而且没有白天出没和仔细观察尸体伤口的细节根本推理不出什么东西）。 ——行，我可以催眠自己杰洛特是顾及希里安全没有下马探查，大雪天影响了猎魔人感官。这是动作片不是侦探片，可以可以勉强接受。

还有剧情改编，是原著不行吗。不是，是编剧驾驭不了原著的深度不敢讨论人性的阴暗面，是剧方为了收视率刻意选择了俗套。这是猎魔人？这不是合家欢迪士尼乐园？ ——当然，至少还算像人写出来的东西，也不是不能看。把原作中直到收到委托才去击杀吸血女妖的杰洛特，改编成站在人类一方，即使明知纳维伦的意愿仍然挥剑的“正义”骑士，也不是不行。大众就好这口，勉强接受。

但是第二集是什么玩意儿？演员新冠🐏了换演员我可以理解，但是从妆容、性格、演员模样，这完完全全就是兰伯特。艾斯卡尔会带妓女上山？我一开始还以为我认错人了。 且不论这个林地矮妖和斯拉夫传说里的没半毛钱关系，其本身也不存在什么寄生转化这种和设定自相矛盾的能力，为什么会让艾斯卡尔被寄生，让他被杀死？编剧是这样表示的：通过亲近之人的死，让杰洛特迅速理解到保护希里的重要性。 我说编剧是不是有病，我可太知道编剧是什么想法了：艾斯卡尔的演员换人了，暂时找不到合适的演员，那干脆就然这个角色下线；但是后面可能还需要一个类似艾斯卡尔的角色，怎么办呢，就让表现令人厌烦的、不好脸谱化的、主流观众不一定喜欢的兰伯特，去死吧你，然后让兰伯特这个角色取代艾斯卡尔的位置，让他变成温柔玩世不恭的游侠形象吧，这一波偷梁换柱我简直是天才。

………………

傻逼。

………………对不起我一般不在网上骂人但是我忍不住了。

游戏里，艾斯卡尔也有一个意外率获得的命运之女——戴德莉·阿德梅恩。你改编成艾斯卡尔被戴德莉杀了或者他杀了命运之女，又或者他回到凯尔莫罕听其他猎魔人说戴德莉政变失败失踪了，然后不顾风雪去寻找她，不是能达到差不多的效果？你们这还搁那演动作戏，演演演，演砍艾斯卡尔（兰伯特）的戏码，叶奈法都被人PUA了还搁这动作戏。原本演员可以来的时候准备怎么拍？那个时候就准备吧艾斯卡尔搞死了？还是说原本准备搞死兰伯特，因为这个演员原本是演兰伯特的？因为他原本就该死所以没签长约，找来的兰伯特的演员才贴近艾斯卡尔的形象因为他就是来演艾斯卡尔的剧本的？

还有妓女来的时候维瑟米尔不出来阻止，杰洛特来阻止？？希里到凯尔莫罕没人惊讶就算了，你还要等兰伯特——我不管那就是兰伯特——进门问了才来个亮明身份。太弱智了，这都不是弱智剧情，这纯粹是犯低级错误，从剪辑逻辑上就是完完全全不合理的。导演编剧至少有一个要背锅。“兰伯特演员是临时找的，这一段是补拍”这种理由我才不接受。

有些观众似乎很喜欢这一季啊，拿IMDB分数和烂番茄新鲜度还有豆瓣作证。但是不论是烂番茄爆米花指数60分不到，MC用户分不到4分，还是最重要的一点，所有平台的评论数量都锐减至少一半，都说明了第二季烂烂烂烂上加烂。

还有一些为政治正确辩驳的用户

第一位在为政治正确辩驳

第二位脑子不好使，搞不清第一位说的什么，更搞不清种族歧视

第一季拍的还行，某些角色被边缘化了，换外貌不那么出众的和黑人演员没关系，印裔的叶奈法在第一季演技还不错所以都可以容忍，但这可不是什么值得称道的事。

什么才是真正的反对种族歧视？ 是实打实的展现北境王国对精灵和矮人的种族仇杀 是不将歧视和非我族类弱化成王国纷争的人类与精灵王国的矛盾 是将血淋淋的现实不加粉饰的展现在人们面前 而不是用就业公平这种由头硬塞黑人演员的做法 白人和部分傻傻的黑人才吃这一套，这样一来不但减缓了黑人的反抗意识，也把白人内部（甚至其他少数族裔）的就业矛盾转移到黑人身上 剧组敢改编一个史凯力根乘船去南方掠夺黑人奴隶或者尼弗迦德征召黑人奴隶上前线的戏码吗？ 敢在剧中放人类对亚人种族惨无人道的火刑架和松鼠党报复性的割喉谋杀吗？ 甚至，剧组敢在剧里加上一段嘲讽亚人种族的童谣吗？

原作表达的类似于“人类之间不论有什么矛盾，其他种族怪物都不过是人类的工具，也许可能是人类的伙伴，但永远不会是人类，不论是精灵、矮人、猎魔人还是怪物。”电视剧里有出现一点点吗？为什么我上面提到“即使明知纳维伦的意愿仍然挥剑的‘正义’骑士”，因为真正的猎魔人基本不会为了委托之外原因去猎杀魔物，除非跟猎魔人自己切身相关，又或者挡住他的路。猎魔人的世界里又各种不同的伦理，猎魔人的伦理，女术士的伦理，精灵的伦理，德鲁伊的伦理，吸血鬼的伦理，人类的伦理，人类的伦理里面还有史凯力根这种和大陆不同的伦理。电视剧有真正去塑造这些不同的伦理吗？还不是一笔带过或者脸谱化处理。这叫什么，这叫美国主义。

我在这放两部剧，真正做到了对政治正确的正面探讨《杰克莱恩（第一季）》《副本（第一季）》对，都只有一季，为什么只有一季值得称道那就去问美国人。 为什么酷儿不再是酷的，为什么平权流于表面不再敢于深入，为什么好的创作者和创作方向不再能获得资源，都去问美国人。不是只有天朝的文娱在走下坡路。沃卓斯基拍不了8被迫去拍黑4，都是一个道理。

就那么一点点价值观的冲突，还依赖着原著，为什么不能用珠玉在前的原著和游戏来对比电视剧？ 甚至脱开前者，电视剧的水平也就将将二流，比CW超英剧强点的水平。烂番茄新鲜度90%就吹吧，真是一等一水平亨利会直接辞演而不是错开档期？

平心而论，第一季我会给4星，第二季我会给2~3星，但是就像冯小刚说的——虽然他不一定对—— “有很多垃圾观众，才形成了这么多的垃圾电影。你如果不去捧场，它就没有生存空间，制片人也不会去制作这些垃圾电影。” Netflix里我vote down，豆瓣我也要打一星，这才是真正尊重影视作品。

第二季渐渐找到画风了，看过的都知道和第一季差距特别大。

之前的问题就是文戏有点文绉绉有点想做史诗的感觉，但编剧美工导演无法合作融洽在Tv这个载体做出来他们要的东西。并且这季故事总算按正常时间线来了，并且没有回忆杀。终于知道观众爱看什么了。可以讲清楚一个故事了。

在这里希望觉得原著还有游戏有区别的高抬贵手别打低分 另一个猎魔人宇宙 难道就不香？游戏党现在宽容多了 希望原著党可以学习。毕竟游戏里，杰洛特死了可以读档，杰洛特做的错误的决定，可以通过读档来获得一个相对好的“小恶”，一个相对好的任务结局。而这里的每一个人在我们如果不知道原著和游戏的剧情，他们做的是唯一且不可以悔改的结局。

为什么威瑟米尔不可以有私心为了自己的孩子们？每一个猎魔人都是他的孩子，一个个死在面前加上Baba Yaga（那个老太太demon）的蛊惑，为什么不能在一瞬间上头伤害了ciri？其他时候 威斯米尔没有演出来一个合格的慈祥的老猎魔人？是真的演出来了有血有肉。

为什么椰奶不可以有私心，看过原著的都知道椰奶可不是道德标杆，三观可一点都不正。满脑子都是力量 美貌 享乐，我觉得剧集已经尽量在凸显危险的蛇蝎美人的魅力并且还让椰奶更加有情有义了

关于说颜色问题的，咱们没有zz的zq问题，理性探讨一下。为什么精灵不能有黄和黑皮的。因为这是凯尔特文化？因为北欧没有颜色？那这个世界 或者任何一个架空世界 也没有颜色？因为作者没写这是个黑人我们要尊重作者？那作者有明确的说精灵里没有黄黑人种了么？多一些宽容 魔幻世界 不是zz剧 不是历史剧 我们想看一个好故事 不要被带了节奏 跟着一些别有用心的人的节奏毁了这个剧。觉得黑皮看的恶心 哪怕你想成兽人也可以 但麻烦不要打低分咱别说出来 豆瓣确实没有国际影响力 但现在还能自由自在说这个颜色问题 咱们都心知肚明就可以了，但因为这样的事情给差评传到国外对咱们国人是不是有影响？

如果没有资本注入，这个剧砍了我们看什么？如果这个ip没热度了 还有什么衍生作品吗？cdpr已经跌落神坛 原著小说没有cdpr在这个年代没有人会注意到这ip的。确实是个好ip 但不要听什么尬吹这个书比肩指环王或者冰与火。

看看剧的诚意。第一季导演炫技砸到脚。第二季知错就改好好讲故事。第一季预算不够有怪物基本都晚上，第二季哪怕特效不是那么好也愿意突破勇敢在白天做怪物打斗。知道看客喜欢看大超巷战，这季也有。知道迎合游戏党，做了很多怪物类型，有注意到吗？杰洛特的剑也变成了两把，在马的背包中。知道是成人向 在这个说任何话都会被zz的zq的情况下 尽量不触碰任何道德和意识形态问题 但给我们漏了成人向的奶¥子，也有脏话和血浆。还有一个华裔猎魔人，舞剑方法都和其他人不一样。包括通缉令从天而降掉到水里，椰奶拿起来指甲里的泥和纸上的水。处处都是细节处处都有诚意。

最后说一下。希望诸位高抬贵手，当年Witcher3出来的时候、没几个人知道1和2。没几个人知道原著。是热爱这个ip的人口口相传授之以鱼仙人指路。希望这个ip可以更好 剧中每一个人物在原著中都有，希望可以看到这些人物在剧中的表现，有文学讲不出来的人物弧光和成长，有游戏看不到的视听语言。

Fuck it. I decided to compile a list of every change between Season 2 and Blood of Elves

Heavy spoilers for the books and Season 2!

\---------------------------------------------------------------

This is not all-encompassing. I'll forget some changes--Heaven knows the writers made enough changes. I'll also preface this by saying: This isn't a commentary on the quality of the season itself. It is simply a collection of the differences between the novel and the show.

**Characters**

* Voleth Meir is not in the books. Completely new character.

* Geralt wouldn't use Ciri as bait in the books. Nor did he.

* Ciri is never possessed by a witch.

* Yennefer does not lose her magic in the books.

* Yennefer never considers sacrificing Ciri for power. Nor does the opportunity ever arise.

* Yennefer is not captured by Niilfgard in the books.

* Instead, she is blinded following Sodden after taking a fireball to the face from Fringilla. She then spends lots of time in recovery, then--on Dijkstra's orders--tails and saves Dandelion from Rience.

* No one ever thinks she's dead in the books either (Geralt worries that she died after Sodden, if I recall, but finds out rather quickly she's still out there after talking to Triss at the Sodden memorial)

* Later in the series (Post Time of Contempt/Late Season 3 or early Season 4 by comparison), people suspect Yennefer of being a Nilfgaardian spy. But at no point does anyone suspect her of being a spy following Sodden.

* The Stregobor stuff isn't a thing in the books. He's there, but plays no important role.

* Vessemir wouldn't try to use Ciri's blood to create more witchers in the books. Nor would he ever allow Ciri to undergo the Trial. Nor would he let Eskel bring a bunch of hookers to Kaer Morhen

* In the books, Dandelion is actively working with Djikstra and the Redanian Secret Service. ~~This is removed in the show~~ It is implied that Djikstra is funding Dandelion's sandpiper activities, though Dandelion doesn't seem to be aware of who he is working with. This is speculative on my part though.

* Also in the books, Dandelion is not nearly as comedic as he was in Season 2. He is funny, but they seemed to lean into that aspect of him for Season 2.

* This is more my interpretation, but in the books, Dandelion is far wittier than he is in the show. He certainly doesn't come across as the type to talk to rats in the book.

* Djikstra is not a rambling drunk in the books (although I didn't find that to be a bad change. It was pretty interesting IMO).

* I don't believe Istredd even appears in Blood of Elves

* Francesa Findabar is *not* with the Scoia'tael in the books. By this, I mean she's not in the field with them, acting as their leader.

* She is a member of the Brotherhood of Sorcerers, though she does harbor sympathies for their cause and occasionally meets with Scoia'tel leaders (Filavandrel, as an example). This relationship becomes relevant when she aids Niilfgaard during the Coup at Thanned

* Fringilla Vigo does not become de facto leader of Cintra in the books. Instead, she fucks off to Niilfgard

* Cahir is not captured by the Brotherhood following Sodden in the books. I don't even recall if he was at Sodden. As far as I recall, he traveled back to Niilfgard following the Fall of Cintra, and was imprisoned for failing to capture Ciri. We don't see him again for another two books after Sodden.

* His execution plot-point never happened in the books.

* Book Cahir is also not nearly as mustache-twirly-evil-villain as he is in the show. Cahir fans will know what I mean.

* Tissaia is hardly a significant character in the books.

* Rience is not a magical bounty hunter in the books. He's an almost fanatical follower of Vilgefortz in the books.

* Rience is scarred in the show and books, but in the books, it's because Yennefer uses her magic to wound him as he's interrogating Dandelion.

* Lydia Van Bredevoort does not develop her scars from sniffing a vial of elder blood in the books. Instead, her scars are a result of magical experimentation on Vilgefortz' orders, and her wounds are hidden with an illusion.

* Eskel is not turned into a Leshen and then killed (as far as we know. He's not in the books for long.)

* Vilgefortz and Tissaia are not a romantic thing, as far as I could tell. Nor are they really even partners. Vilgefortz is also the genuine champion of Sodden in the books. He does this to gain more authority in the Brotherhood.

* Vilgy is also way stronger and smarter in the books then how he is depicted in the show. Also, Vilgy never says his classic line. This is a cardinal sin, imo.

* Nenekke is an old and religious lady. She doesn't go around dropping f-bombs in the books.

* Emhyr kept the fact that Ciri was his daughter a big secret in the books. Understandable, given his plans for her (**cough** Imperial Incest **cough**)

* Jarre in the books is a bit of a geek, who is very clearly awkward around girls, and has a crush on Ciri. But he's also smart, and good-intentioned. The show reduces him to a dick joke.

**Plot Points**

* Except for Ciri's training, there is not a single fight at Kaer Morhen. Never. There is no Leshen, nor is there the centipede thing with the claws. There is no possession.

* There are only four witchers at Kaer Morhen (Vessemir, Eskel, Lambert, and Coen)

* At Kaer Morhen, Ciri trains and exercises. Eventually, Triss arrives (on Geralt's request) and instructs Ciri on the basics of magic, as well as the Elder language.

* The plot point with Ciri's blood being able to make more witchers is not in the books.

* Vesemir never collects her blood either. The thought of making more witchers is only ever entertained in the context of Ciri being raised as a girl vs. being raised as a witcher. But the mutagenic process itself/Trial of Grasses is never brought up.

* In the book, Triss travels with Ciri and Geralt to the Temple. In the show, she doesn't. We don't see her get sick.

* On the path to the Temple is when they run into Yarpen Zigrin again. This doesn't happen in the show. As a result, Ciri doesn't visit Shaerrawedd, and there is no fight with the Scoia'tael.

* There is no fight at Melitele's Temple in the books. Never.

* Yennefer does not travel to the Temple to kidnap Ciri and sacrifice her in the books.

* In the books, Ciri and Yennefer stay at the temple for a while. Ciri learns more magic.

* Yennefer is invited to the temple by Geralt after Geralt has already left. See the 'Dear Friend,' bullet point further down.

* There is no reunion between Geralt and Yennefer in Blood of Elves. They reunite outside Gors Velen in the next book.

* In the books, Rience does not find Ciri at the Temple. Instead, Geralt leaves Ciri in Nenekke's care to find Rience at Oxenfurt.

* There is no Shani in the show. >:(

* Phillipa does not help Geralt find Rience, nor does she help Rience escape: as she does in the books.

* In fact, Rience doesn't meet Ciri till the Time of Contempt, which is the next book following Blood of Elves.

* Dandelion doesn't sing at a tavern in Oxenfurt. He sings at Bleobheris, a sacred tree.

* His Sandpiper plot is not a thing in the books.

* Dandelion is not arrested in the books.

* The elf and Cintra plot is not in the books.

* There is a non-human uprising in the North in the books, led by the Scoia'tael, but they are not given Cintra as a place of refuge by the Niilfgardians. Instead, Niilfgard is suspected of funding and arming them behind the scenes to stoke instability in the North.

* Francesca never gets pregnant. Nor does Emhyr commit infanticide against an elven baby in the books.

* The notion that a pure-blooded elf hasn't been born in decades is also a Netflix invention. Elves have a much smaller window of time to get pregnant, but it still happens in the books. Avallach and Geralt talk about this in Tower of Swallow.

* The magical politics is a thing in the books, but is very different from the magical politics in the show. Stregobor does not interrogate or harm Yennefer, and neither do Tissaia/Vilgy use that as an excuse to seize Council seats.

* Instead, the magical politics in the book are concerned with the growing distrust between the Kings and their magical advisors

* The meeting of the Kings at the end of Season 2 is the meeting of the Kings in BoE that puts the Mages on edge, and is used to justify the Conclave in Time of Contempt. However, Tissaia is at the King's meeting in the show, which is not the case in the book. No mages were invited to the meeting in the books.

* When the Kings of the North meet, they do conclude it best to kill Ciri--so as to prevent her falling into Emhyr's hands (they don't want him to have a legitimate claim to the Cintran throne). However, the show cut the King's talk of war with Niilfgaard.

* In the books, they believe a quick strike across the Yaruga could recapture Cintra, and deal a blow to the South. This conversation paves the way for the Second Great War, but does not happen in the show.

* The show also leaves out the politics regarding Cintra's throne. Cordhingrer is visited by Geralt in the books, and they develop a plot to--essentially-- smear Calanthe's name and ruin her claim to the Cintrant throne, thus making Ciri's claim to the throne illegitimate. Thus, protecting her from the kings who want her dead for her political power.

* Again, the Voleth Meir plot is not in the books at all. Instead, Blood of Elves focuses on Ciri's training and planting the seeds for future conflicts.

* I.e. the Second Great War, the Coup of Thanned, Character's motivations to capture Ciri, etc.

* The Monoliths are not a thing in the books.

* The 'Dear Friend,' bit is in reference to letters exchanged by Yennefer and Geralt while Geralt is in Oxenfurt hunting for Rience. Geralt asks Yennefer to travel to the temple to train Ciri. Again, Geralt and Yen don't actually meet though.

* In the books, Niilfgardians are depicted as something more akin to the Romans or English (Highly centralized government with progressive and aristocratic traditions and legal codes). In the books, they are not religious zealots. Though they are also not necessarily 'good' either.

* Yennefer and Cahir never have a team-up in the books.

* Tissaia does not recommend that Ciri be captured, nor does she suggest that anyone protecting her be captured as well. In fact, Tissaia's role in the show is dramatically overblown.

* Ciri is not with Geralt when he meets Nivellen.

* Istredd does not meet with Cordringer and Fenn in the books. Geralt does meet them to find information about Rience and Ciri.

It's not an exaggeration to say that the *majority* of this season is different from the books. And not just sort of different, but drastically different. Hell, the last four or five episodes are fictitious (relative to the book canon (yes I know it's all fiction, please stop reminding me)) in nearly every way. At this point, I'm not certain where the story will go. For example, how will the Coup play out on Thanedd if Ciri won't be able to attend it? And if Ciri isn't at Aretuza for the Coup, then how will she be warped to the desert? And if she isn't separated from Geralt and Yennefer, then how will she meet up with the Rats?

Obviously, they can still work these plots in, or at least, work in the *effects* of these plots, but the story will take a drastically different turn than the one the book tells.

Note that this isn't necessarily a good or a bad thing, so long as it's done well. But there has to come a point when the adaptation is so drastically different from the source material, that I start to wonder whether it's truly an adaptation, or if it's a reimagining.

最近把《猎魔人》第二季看完了，8集嫌短，欲罢不能。

如果你欧美奇幻作品爱好者，指环王、哈利波特这些电影，那么不要错过本片。

猎魔人是一个非常优质的IP，原著小说豆瓣评分8.6-9.7，妥妥的神作。这个书我看了一半，还是很有意思。吉洛特咒骂一声，拔剑就打。杰洛特咒骂不停。还有碎嘴兄弟吟游诗人、矮人、变形怪，各种好玩的。

书的容量和载体，比影视剧大太多了，有兴趣的试着去看看。

这个小说后来被改编成游戏《巫师》，也是名气和口碑上乘的佳作。喜欢单机游戏的值得玩玩。

至于《猎魔人》电视，第几季剧情有点凌乱，看得人摸不着头脑，全靠男主大超的颜值和整体画面质量过硬拉分，拉到7.5分左右，属于能看的层级。

第二季显然剧组吸取了教训，剧情方面简洁明了很多。画面再次提升，看得我赞叹不止。差不多——相当于看了八级《指环王》《霍比特人》吧。非常值得一看。

看完电视，我想把小说再刷一遍了。

放些图片、参考资料。

安杰伊·萨普科夫斯基（Andrzej Sapkowski），波兰奇幻作家。1948年6月21日生于波兰罗兹，大学主修经济学，后担任高级销售代表，自翻译小说开始文学生涯，走上写作之路。1986年，其短篇小说《猎魔人》发表于波兰知名幻想文学杂志，在读者及评论家中取得极高评价。此后他延续这一世界观创作了多部作品，“猎魔人”系列成为他的代表作，波兰前总理唐纳德•图斯克更将该书作为国礼赠送给美国前总统巴拉克•奥巴马。安杰伊•萨普科夫斯基先后五次获得波兰幻想文学最高荣誉“扎伊德尔奖”，获颁波兰文化及国家遗产部授予的文化功绩奖章，为东欧最著名的奇幻小说作家。

有些改编是可取的，比如让希瑞加入童话的真实性（真爱如血）这一短篇中，可以避免犯第一季时间线混乱的错误。贯穿整季的林中老妪也是不错的原创内容，她引出了叶妮芙的故事，而且最后和整个世界最大的威胁狂猎联系在一起，有始有终，all make sense了。

猎魔人Eskel和第一季的莫斯萨克类似，虽然他们一直活到游戏第三部，但剧中因为后续戏份不多早早领了便当。可是Eskel完全颠覆原本冷静理智的形象，乖张而莽撞，忘记怪物的致命要害，甚至带一群风尘女子到凯尔莫罕（非常非常非常离谱，网飞一定付给了安杰伊老爷子一大笔钱才能让他忍受这样的桥段），活脱脱一个差生模样。

Francesca是一个术士，也是个政治动物，而不是被复仇冲昏头脑的绝望母亲。她在将来的仙尼德岛政变中要扮演关键角色，剧中她和术士协会完全没了瓜葛，真不知道这段故事要如何发展。

维瑟米尔想利用希瑞，甚至叶妮芙也想利用希瑞，还出现了杰洛特挥剑指向叶妮芙的场景。这些改编不仅仅是让原著党无法满意的问题，对角色形象和人物关系的影响也是很大的。劳伦-施密特-希斯里斯对“灰色道德观”的理解似乎有些浅薄，让角色做蠢事或坏事并不能体现这一点。

杰洛特变成了一个男妈妈的样子。他的倔脾气，他的冷幽默，他常常不合时宜的原则性，他努力想藏但藏不住的正义感，他偶尔流露出的孩子气，他面对一个突如其来的青少年养女的手足无措，这些全都无影无踪。这个杰洛特太完美，缺少了很多魅力。

相对来说，更喜欢第一季让我觉得太油的亚斯克尔了。他成了最与众不同的角色。

台词一直飘在天上，完全没有烟火气——生活质感本来是猎魔人作为一部奇幻小说很独特的亮点。

所有猎魔的过程都有着一致的节奏：先把气氛烘托到位，简短的交手后一刀毙命。是缺钱了吗？

总结，劳伦-施密特-希斯里斯的剧作水平不太担得起《猎魔人》，她的才华在原著作者面前犹如火苗面对火炉。

三星。没玩过游戏没看过原著，时间线统一以后观感比第一季好很多，但是给我的体验不如第一季，很多剧情看得我血压上升。精灵有个孩子就不想干了，要休养生息？？最后猎魔人被偷家那段，除了男主之外的猎魔人看着都有点菜，本来人就不多，又没了好几个。如果编剧是想表达战斗的艰难，那我只能说那些恐龙看起来不是很能打的样子（可能两季看下来习惯了），希里明知道家人都不在了+听到了男主的呼唤还是安心沉溺幻境，两季下来的成长呢？如果想表达她冲破幻境的艰难，起码看起来更警觉挣扎痛苦一点？我看着她挺安心挺欢乐的。两季下来，对希里的身世/为什么被追杀各种伏笔，但是感觉看了个寂寞，回想一下，好像主线剧情并没有什么进展，每次刚感觉要有突破了就已经是最后一集了。反派的身份挺出乎意料的，但可能因为前面基本没有铺垫，并没有大反转的惊喜，只有一头问号。反正亨利也不演了，我也不用纠结了